Home  |  Contact Us
what's new on Revach
Motza'ei Shabbos Dress Code, To Change or Not to Change

Leil HaSeder Alone in The Shadow of Corona

Stopping Corona: Overwhelmed With Eitzos?

Parshas Tzav: Rabbeinu Bachaye - Covering the Shame of Sinners

Parshas Pinchas: Rav Yehonoson Eibshitz - Where did Zimri the Great Tzaddik go Wrong?

 
[view all articles in this category]

Section: Halacha   Category: Tshuvos
Rav Moshe Shternbuch: Birchas HaMazon with Zimun for Three Woman
The gemara (Brachos 45b) says that women and men cannot be counted together to form a Mizuman for Birchas HaMazon. The opinion of the Vilna Gaon is that three women eating together without any men present have an obligation to Bench BiMizuman. Furthermore says the Vilna Gaon in places where it is not customary for women to form a Mizuman, women should make sure not to eat in groups of three because that would obligate them to make a Mizuman.

Rav Moshe Shternbuch (end of 4:51) asks if women want to make a Mizuman together even though it is not customary, is it permissible. He answers that it is not advisable for a number of reasons. First he says, it comes off as arrogant. Additionally he says that there is an Issur of Lo Sisgodadu for a public to act not in accordance with the customs of the city. Since three people is called a public and women are not Noheg today to make a Mizuman there is a question of Lo Sisgodadu.

Lastly he says Zimun is considered a Bracha even though there is no Shem and Malchus in it. This being the case according to Rebbi Akiva Eiger it would be considered a Bracha Livatala according to the opinions that three women do not form a Zimun. Therefore advise Rav Shternbuch, it is better to be rewarded for abstaining and honoring the Minhag of Klal Yisroel, rather than be Machmir in accordance with an opinion of the Vilna Gaon that was never accepted.


Important Note: We bring this tshuvah as a starting point for discussion and not to convey any halacha. We try to convey the Tshuva to the best of our ability. We admit that our understanding may not be accurate. One should learn the tshuva to verify the accuracy of our interpretation. Please understand that this Tshuva may not be the final word on this topic. One should consult a Rav before drawing any conclusions.


 
send your commentsprintable versionemail to a friend

 
Perek Shira
Perek Shira: The Snake's Song - Taking a Plunge

No creature in history has taken a fall like the snake.  This once companion of man, with legs that would...read full story

Zechiras Miriam

Rav Michel Yehuda Lefkowitz: How To Achieve The Ever Elusive Ahavas HaBriyos

If you look at the lives of many of the great tzaddikim, they...read full story

Story
Pitum HaKitores: Imrei Emes of Ger - Some Things Smell Better Than A Good Smell

When the Imrei Emes was crowned the new Rebbe of Ger he took a stand against the tendency for the...read full story

Special Tefilos

A Special War Time Tefila By The Ramchal

The one and only Keil - Gird me with strength for war, bring my rivals to their knees...read full story