A r c h i v e s
|Section: Questions Category: Hashkafa|
|Hashkafa - gemara|
|Submitted by michael gray Answered by Rabbi Tzvi Frank|
I believe the answer to that question is that American Roshei Yeshiva feel/felt that intellectual stimulation is imperative to keep today's American youth within the walls of the bais medrash. They are not arguing whether R' Shach's derech halimud is correct. Indeed, they themselves grew into the Roshei Yeshiva that they have become through Rav Shach's m'halach. The question is, with today's environment in America, is learning with the "correct" derech enough to prevent our bochurim from seeking their intellectual stimulation elsewhere? Eis laasos L'Hashem!
Your comments are welcome!
|posted:2008-04-22 14:53:53 |
|Hashkafa - "Zissen" Pesach|
|Submitted by Susan Glodstein Answered by Rabbi Tzvi Frank|
Zissen translates simply into "sweet"
Have a sweet Peasach!
|posted:2008-04-15 10:48:05 |
|Hashkafa - Elijah's cup|
|Submitted by Ben Lazar Answered by Rabbi Tzvi Frank|
To date I haven't found a source for this legend.
Actually, it is not clear from all sources that Eliyahu actually visits the Seder but rather that it is only symbolic that we hope and pray for him to come. There are sources though who do indeed feel that Eliyahu visits the seder similar to a bris and that we anounce Boruch Habaah! at the time of the door opening to welcome his visit. No mention of sipping the wine though...
I would not dismiss this legend out of hand though. More research is required. My experience shows that minhagim held as true by a good portion of klal yisrael usually started from somewhere. We just have to keep looking.
Hope this helps,
|posted:2008-04-15 10:35:28 |
|Hashkafa - Where oh Where has Pesach Gone?|
|Submitted by Daniel F Answered by Rabbi Tzvi Frank|
Pesach is about going back to the basics?
I don't think that the issue at hand is about Pesach at all. Provided that the ingredients are kosher for Pesach there should be no halachic problem.
I mean where do you draw the line? A really talented balabusta can produce a mouth watering Pesach cake that rivals most of the mediocre fare I have to deal with throughout the year. I remember when Pesach cakes meant this dry, eggshell pitted, yellow mass that would have permanently glued your tongue to your palate were it not for the borsht that came to the rescue. I see no one proclaiming how dare that woman bake such a delicious tasting cake! Stick to the Macaroons like in the Alte Heim! Farkert, the more effort you put into simchas yom tov and oineg yom tov the more you'll be rewarded (quite literally).
The issue at hand is why are we so "megusham" that we experience a void when we lack Kosher LaPesach Pepperoni Pizza? Why do we feel withdrawal symptoms when Kosher LaPesach meatballs and spaghetti are not on the menu? The manufacturers are only supplying a demand for these products. I have no issue with them. Once these products are available with a reliable hashgocho, I have no problem with their consumption. The issue is rather with the source of this demand; for it reveals a real and thriving connection with our gashmiyos when in truth we are a nation that strives to be connected with ruchniyos. This is unsettling to the older generation. They see an alarming indication that our priorities are perhaps polluted due to the relative comfort in which we find ourselves and that is why they are quick to point out how frugally they themselves were raised.
I quite agree to this sentiment. I would continue expanding upon this thought but my Kosher LaPesach Pancakes are getting cold. Would you know if they came out with Kosher LaPesach maple syrup yet?
|posted:2008-04-14 10:13:23 |
|Hashkafa - Passover-I don't speak Hebrew|
|Submitted by lula clements Answered by Rabbi Tzvi Frank|
Yes. Passover begins at Sundown April 19th (Saturday night) and ends on Sunday night, April 27th.
Ouside of Israel, the Seder is held on the first two nights, Saturday night and Sunday night.
|posted:2008-04-14 08:42:14 |
|Hashkafa - Pesach Seder Topics|
|Submitted by C. Kluger Answered by Rabbi Tzvi Frank|
There is a minhag brought down in sefarim that one should recount his own nissim that he personally experienced and one should articulate his own individual ge'ula from shi'bud l'cheirus. Some mefarshim explain "v'noimar l'fanuv shira chadasha" in this manner as it is presented b'lashon hoiveh rather than in the past tense.
Nevertheless, the main chiyuv of Pesach night is definitely Sippur Y'tzias Mitzrayim which includes expounding on the Haggadah. So, if an individual did indeed go through an unfortunate period of shi'bud and subsequently was redeemed and went out l'cheirus, according to the above mentioned minhag, he should apportion some time to relate his own personal "nes" to his children. On the other hand those of us in current times, who B'chasdei Hashem are growing up in a malchus shel chesed, should rather focus on Sippur Yitzius Mitzrayim like the rest of Klal Yisrael for thousands of years.
May we all be zoicheh to see the true ge'ulah, b'vias HaMoshiach and personally be able to recount to our children the nissim that Hashem will do for us Bekarov B'yamaeinu.
|posted:2008-04-09 14:39:45 |
|Displaying 16-21 of 21 (Page 2 / 2) |
| 1 2