Revach L'Neshama http://revach.net/ RSS feed for - Section: DAF YOMI Copyright 2007, Revach L'Neshama en-US Revach L'Neshama Logo 144 31 http://revach.net/img/small_header.jpg http://revach.net/ info@revach.net Sat, 09 Dec 2017 03:00:00 -0800 240 Shevuos 4 - SUMMARY 1.  There are conflicting Stam Mishnayos regarding Lav She’ein Bo Maaseh because Rebbi changed his mind but left the first one as is.  (1) 2.  In order to say the Mishna by Yetzios Shabbos is talking about Malkos, you must hold that Lokin Al Lav SheNitein L’Azharas Misas Bais Din.  (2) 3.  The Mishna cannot be talking about Malkos because Tumah could not be She’heim Arba if it were B’Meizid. 4.  The gemara suggests that Rebbi held like Rebbi Yishmael by Tumah and Rebbi Akiva by Shvua.  (3) 5.  Rebbi cannot hold like Rebbi Akiva by Shvua because Rebbi darshans Klal Prat (Martzei’a) while Rebbi Akiva learns Shvua L’SheAvar brings a Korban because he darshans Ribuy Mi’ut.  (4) 6.  Rebbi agrees that you darshan Ribuy Mi’ut when the two Klalim are adjacent to each other like by Pidyon HaBen.
 
**A BIT MORE**
1.  This is only in the Hava Amina when we still think that the Mishna is Rebbi Yishmael. 2.  Only Rebbi Yishmael and not Rebbi Akiva 3.  According to Rav Kahana this was Rebbi’s own opinion. 4.  According to the Maskanas HaGemara on 5a.

]]>
Shevuos 3 - SUMMARY 1.  Shavuos is after Makos because ends with the issurim of shaving which are 5 for one hasra’as and Shavuos starts with Shtayim She’heim Arba. 2.  Since Shavuos and Yedias HaTuma are written in the same parsha, the Mishna writes those two as well as all the other that are Shtayim She’heim Arba. 3.  Although Shavuos is listed first, the Mishna first deals with Tumah since it is small we deal with it and finish with it. 4.  The 2 of Shavua are the future, “I will eat” and “I  will not eat”.  The additional two are the same in past tense. 5.  The 2 of Tuma are forgetting tumah and eating Kodesh or going into the Mikdash.  The additional two are remembering the tumah and forgetting Kodesh or Mikdash. 6.  The 2 of Yetzios Shabbos are Hotza’a of the Ba’al HaBayis or Ani.  The additional two are the Hachnasa of these two. 7.  The 2 of Nega’im are Se’ais and Bahares.  The additional two are their Toldos. 8.  Rebbi Yishmael holds that you are only Chayav for future Shavuos, although the gemara tries to say that this is only for a Korban and not Malkos.  (1) 9.  Rebbi Akiva holds that you are only Chayav for forgetting Tumah and not Kodesh or Mikdash.  (2) 10.  If the Mishna is Rebbi Yishmael and he holds that you get Malkos for Shavua L’She’Avar, he must hold Lav She’Ein Bo Maaseh Lokin Alav. 11.  According to above our Mishna is a Stam Mishna that holds Lav She’Ein Bo Maaseh Lokin Alav, and Rebbi Yochanan paskens like Stam Mishna. 12.  Rabbi Yochanan holds Lav She’Ein Bo Maaseh Ein Lokin Alav and must have another Stam Mishna if our Mishna is Rebbi Yishmael. 13.  Nosar had no Malkos either because it is Lav She’Ein Bo Maaseh or because it is Nituk LaAseh.  (3)
 
**A BIT MORE**
1.  To try answer that he is the Tanna of the Mishna and holds that Shavua is Shtayim She’heim Arba. 2.  Not like the Mishna 3.  Machlokes Rebbi Yaakov and Rebbi Yehuda

]]>