Revach L'Neshama http://revach.net/ RSS feed for - Section: DAF YOMI Copyright 2007, Revach L'Neshama en-US Revach L'Neshama Logo 144 31 http://revach.net/img/small_header.jpg http://revach.net/ info@revach.net Mon, 13 Aug 2018 03:00:00 -0700 240 Menachos 4 - SUMMARY 1. Rebbi Hoshaya is Misupak whether a Mincha L’Shem Zevach is pasul Shelo Lishmo according to Rebbi Shimon since he doesn’t know if Rebbi Shimon’s reason is like Rabba or Rava. (1) 2. Minchas Chotei & Sotah are pasul Shelo Lishma because it says “He” like by Chatos. 3. The extra money of Minchas Chotei & Sotah and Asham are used for Olas Nedava for the Mizbei’ach. 4. An Asham when the owner already brought a different one is sent out to pasture until it gets a Mum. If it is accidentally nishchat before it has a mum then if it was already given over to the shepherd it is kasher for an Olah. 5. A Minchas Omer is pasul Shelo Lishma since it is a matir that failed. It is not listed in the Mishna because it is a Korban Tzibbur, is brought as an accessory to a Korban, and has a Zman Kavua. 6. Asham Nazir and Mitzora are pasul shelo lishma becasue they are failed machshirim. They are not listed in the Mishna because other Ashamos are kasher. 7. A Machshir shelo lishma is pasul, while a michaper shelo lishma is kasher. 8. Similarly a Machshir is not brought after Misa while a Michaper is. 9. In the korbanos of a yoledes, the Chatos is considered a Machshir while the Olah is the Michaper. 10. If a Nazir sets aside money for his korbanos and dies, if the money was not labeled then Halacha LMoshe MiSinai says it all goes for Nedava. 11. If the money of the deceased Nazir was labeled the Chatos goes to Yam HaMelech, Olah and Shlamim go for Olah and Shlamim. 12. Although the Olah and Shlamim.of a Nazir are Machshirim they are still brought after Misa because theye are not Kavua since any of the three Korbanos of a Nazir are Machshir.
 
**A BIT MORE**
1. According to Rabba it is kasher since it is obviously not a Zevach. According to Rava it is pasul since only kavana for another mincha is kasher.

]]>
Menachos 2 - SUMMARY 1. Mishna - Mincha Shelo Lishma Is Kasher but is not credited to the owner. 2. A Mincha that one avodah was done Shelo Lishma must still be completed Lishma. 3. Rebbi Shimon says in one place Mincha Shelo Lishma satifies the Baal obligation and in one place not. Rav Ashi says it depends if he said the word Mincha or not. Raba is Michalek whether he changed the Baal or the Korban. Rava whether he said for another mincha or a Korban. 4. Our Mishna that says the Mincha Shelo Lishma does not help the Baal, can only be Rebbi Shimon according to Rav Ashi. (1)
 
**A BIT MORE**
1. Since our Mishna gives an example where he changed the Korban it cannot be Rebbi Shimon according to Raba. And because it is talking about another Mincha and not Korban it cannot be Rebbi Shimon according to Rava.

]]>